THE JEWISH THEOLOGIAN WHO BELIEVED IN THE RESURRECTION
Dr. Pinchas Lapide, Jewish theologian, Israeli diplomat & New Testament scholar“I accept the resurrection of Jesus not as a matter of theology but as a historical event. The transformation of the disciples from a shattered, demoralized group into the most dynamic missionary movement in history cannot be explained without a real, bodily resurrection. As a Jew, I believe God raised Jesus of Nazareth from the dead.” Lapide’s conclusion — as a practicing Jew who did not become a Christian — that the resurrection was a real historical event is one of the most remarkable and unexpected affirmations of the resurrection in modern scholarship. Evidence: Historical analysis of the disciples’ transformation, the empty tomb tradition, and the rapid spread of resurrection belief in Jerusalem. [Ontology: Jesus > The Resurrection Response]+ Read More
File Under: The Resurrection
Cross Reference: Secular Corroboration
Habermas’s Minimal-Facts Argument — and Its Limits
“For I delivered unto you first of all that which I also received, how that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures; And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures.” — Paul, 1 Corinthians 15:3–4 (KJV)Gary HabermasAttributed to Valentin de Boulogne, Saint Paul Writing His Epistles, Wikimedia Commons. The painting is later devotional art, not a portrait of the historical Paul. Gary Habermas
A modern Christian philosopher and historian of the resurrection who argues from a selected group of historical claims he calls minimal facts. His argument is an inference to the best explanation, not a neutral statement of universal scholarly agreement. uses a minimal-facts methodAttributed to Valentin de Boulogne, Saint Paul Writing His Epistles, Wikimedia Commons. Minimal facts
Historical claims selected because their proponents argue that they receive substantial acceptance among critical scholars. The selection and level of agreement remain debated; “minimal facts” is not itself a consensus list. . He emphasizes claims such as Jesus’s crucifixion, the disciples’ resurrection belief, Paul’s conversion and James’s reported encounter. The method distinguishes historical data from the conclusion drawn from that data. The earliest Christian source quoted here is 1 Corinthians 15:3–8Attributed to Valentin de Boulogne, Saint Paul Writing His Epistles, Wikimedia Commons. 1 Corinthians 15:3–8
Paul says that Christ died, was buried, was raised and appeared to Cephas, the Twelve, more than five hundred people, James, all the apostles and Paul himself. The passage is primary evidence for what Paul proclaimed; it does not independently prove that each appearance occurred. . Paul says that Christ died, was buried, was raised and appeared to named groups, including JamesSaint James the Just, Orthodox icon, Wikimedia Commons. The icon is later religious art, not a first-century portrait. James
Paul names James among those to whom Christ appeared. This supports the historical claim that Paul knew of a James associated with the movement; it does not, by itself, establish the psychological cause of James’s belief or prove that he converted from skepticism. . Paul’s own claim to have experienced an appearance is also explicit. The text is early and important, but historians still debate what best explains the experiences, whether the empty tomb should be included among the minimal facts, and how much weight should be assigned to later Gospel narratives.Data, Interpretation and Disagreement
Habermas’s argument is strongest when it distinguishes claims that can be discussed historically from theological conclusions. Jesus’s crucifixion is supported by multiple early sources, including Paul and non-Christian references. Paul’s letters demonstrate that he believed he had encountered the risen Jesus. First Corinthians 15 also shows that James was included in the resurrection proclamation known to Paul. The empty tomb is more disputed. Some scholars accept it as historical; others do not. It therefore should not be described as a fact accepted by nearly all critical scholars without qualification. Likewise, the statement that “no naturalistic hypothesis explains all four facts” is an apologetic conclusion requiring argument, not an independently established historical datum. The 1 Corinthians tradition is especially important because Paul says he “received” and “delivered” the material concerning Christ’s death, burial, resurrection and appearances. The passage demonstrates the early circulation of resurrection claims. It does not enable a historian to observe the resurrection event itself, and it does not force agreement on the best explanation. The card therefore presents Habermas’s case fairly: the minimal-facts approach narrows the debate to selected historical claims, but the selection of facts, the degree of scholarly agreement and the inference to resurrection remain contested.Evidence – 1 Corinthians 15:3–8; Galatians 1:18–19; Galatians 2:9; the crucifixion traditions in the Pauline letters and the Gospel accounts; and the early historical claims preserved in Paul’s correspondence.
Conclusion – Habermas’s method shows how an apologetic resurrection argument can begin with historical claims rather than with the conclusion. It does not demonstrate that every “minimal fact” is accepted by all critical scholars, and the final explanation remains the central point of debate.
Criticisms – The list of minimal facts changes between presentations; scholarly agreement is difficult to quantify; the empty tomb is disputed; Paul’s experience and James’s experience are reported through ancient testimony rather than independently observed; and the move from experiences and testimony to a bodily resurrection is an inference, not a directly measurable event.
Citation – 1 Corinthians 15:3–8; Galatians 1:18–19; Galatians 2:9; Gary R. Habermas and Michael R. Licona, The Case for the Resurrection of Jesus, Kregel, 2004.
File Under – Jesus Christ > The Resurrection > Minimal Facts
Cross References – The Empty Tomb | Resurrection Appearances | Secular Corroboration