# The Big Bang

- Link: https://staging.theevidenceforgod.com/science-nature/the-big-bang/
- Published: 2026-08-06T21:58:42+00:00
- Author: EFG Staff

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Eric Lerner, plasma physicist and author
> “The big bang today relies on a growing number of hypothetical entities, things
> that we have never observed—inflation, dark matter and dark energy are the most
> prominent examples. Without them, there is a fatal contradiction between the observations
> made by astronomers and the predictions of the big bang theory.”From an ‘Open 
> Letter to the Scientific Community’ published in New Scientist (2004) and signed
> by 34 prominent scientists, critiquing the model’s reliance on unverified parameters.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Sir Fred Hoyle, astrophysicist and cosmologist
> “As a result of all this, the main efforts of investigators have been in papering
> over holes in the big bang theory, to build up an idea that has become ever more
> complex and cumbersome.”From ‘The Intelligent Universe’ (1983). Hoyle, who originally
> coined the term “Big Bang” as a critique, favored a Steady State universe without
> a singular explosive beginning.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Paul Steinhardt, theoretical physicist and Albert Einstein Professor in Science
> at Princeton University
> “The Big Bang theory, as it is usually presented, relies on the inflationary model,
> which has become so flexible that it is immune to experimental and observational
> tests… A theory that can predict anything, predicts nothing.”From a 2014 critique
> in Scientific American. Steinhardt, an original architect of inflationary theory,
> became its most prominent skeptic, arguing it renders the model unscientific.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Sir Roger Penrose, mathematical physicist and Nobel Laureate in Physics
> “The Big Bang was not the beginning. There was something before the Big Bang and
> that something is what we will have in our future… in this crazy theory of mine,
> that remote future becomes the Big Bang of another aeon.”Stated during a 2020 
> interview following his Nobel Prize win, explaining his ‘Conformal Cyclic Cosmology’
> which replaces a singular Big Bang with infinite cosmological cycles.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Halton Arp, astronomer and observational cosmologist
> “If quasars are born from active galaxies… then the expanding universe concept
> is based on a false assumption. The redshift is not a velocity indicator, but 
> a measure of the age of the matter.”From ‘Seeing Red: Redshifts, Cosmology and
> Academic Science’ (1998), arguing that intrinsic redshift measurements invalidate
> the core expansion premise of Big Bang cosmology.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Hannes Alfvén, plasma physicist and Nobel Laureate in Physics
> “The Big Bang is a myth, a wonderful myth maybe, which deserves a place of honor
> in the columbarium which already contains the Indian myth of a cyclic Universe…
> the Ptolemaic cosmological myth, and many others.”From ‘Cosmology: Myth or Science?’(
> 1978). Alfvén rejected Big Bang cosmology for ignoring the role of plasma physics
> and electromagnetism in shaping the universe.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Geoffrey Burbidge, professor of physics and astronomy at UC San Diego
> “Big Bang cosmology is probably as widely believed as has been any theory of the
> universe in the history of Western civilization. It rests, however, on many untested,
> and in many cases, untestable, assumptions… it has become a bandwagon of thought
> that reflects faith as much as objective truth.”From his article ‘Why the Big 
> Bang is Wrong’ in Scientific American (1992), challenging the scientific consensus
> and its resistance to alternative cosmological models.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Jayant Narlikar, astrophysicist and emeritus professor at IUCAA
> “The standard big bang cosmology… requires a set of parameters fine-tuned to fit
> the observations. It is reminiscent of the epicycles of Ptolemy. One has to continually
> add new assumptions to save the theory.”From ‘An Introduction to Cosmology’ (2002),
> where Narlikar advocates for the Quasi-Steady State Cosmology as a simpler alternative
> to the increasingly convoluted Big Bang model.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Sir John Maddox, theoretical physicist and former editor of Nature
> “In all respects save that of convenience, this view of the origin of the universe
> is thoroughly unsatisfactory. For one thing, the implication is that there was
> an instant at which time began and that, until that instant, there was no time.
> This is an idea that is logically difficult to grasp and scientifically objectionable.”
> From a controversial 1989 editorial in Nature titled ‘Down with the Big Bang’,
> arguing against the philosophical and scientific implications of a singular cosmic
> beginning.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> David Merritt, astrophysicist and professor at Rochester Institute of Technology
> “The standard cosmological model is a classic example of a degenerating research
> program. Rather than making predictions that are subsequently verified, it is 
> constantly adjusted to accommodate new data, often by postulating unobservable
> entities like dark matter and dark energy.”From a 2017 paper applying philosopher
> Imre Lakatos’s criteria for scientific progress to cosmology, arguing the Big 
> Bang model survives primarily through ad hoc modifications.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Sir Fred Hoyle, astrophysicist and cosmologist
> “The idea that all matter was created in one fell swoop at a finite time in the
> past seems to me an unnecessary and perhaps indefensible extrapolation.”From public
> lectures and debates (1957) arguing for the steady-state alternative and questioning
> the philosophical and physical implications of a temporal cosmic beginning.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Hermann Bondi, mathematical physicist & co-creator of Steady State cosmology
> “It is a major philosophical leap to go from the observed expansion to the conclusion
> that the universe began in a singular event.”Reflecting on cosmological assumptions(
> 1970s) and emphasizing the conceptual risk of inferring an absolute beginning 
> purely from expanding spacetime.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Sir Roger Penrose, mathematical physicist and Nobel Laureate in Physics
> “The singularity at t = 0 is not a physical event but a breakdown of our theories.”
> Highlighting the limits of general relativity (1965–1980) and warning that mathematical
> infinities signal incomplete physics rather than an absolute physical origin.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> William H. McCrea, theoretical physicist and astronomer
> “What is most important is that we must beware of conflating mathematical extrapolation
> with physical reality.”Stated during cosmological discussions (1980s), warning
> that mathematical back-projection does not necessarily describe the physical history
> of the universe.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Yakov Zeldovich, theoretical physicist and cosmologist
> “The cosmological constant could be resurrected to avoid the need for a singular
> origin.”Demonstrating (1990) how modified field equations or non-zero cosmological
> constants offer mathematical paths around an absolute initial singularity.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Geoffrey Burbidge, professor of physics and astrophysics
> “I would not say the Big Bang is proven; there remain reasonable alternative interpretations
> of the evidence.”From interviews and scientific panels (1996), maintaining that
> cosmic microwave background and nucleosynthesis observations permit non-standard
> interpretations.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Jayant Narlikar, astrophysicist & emeritus professor at IUCAA
> “The cosmic microwave background could have explanations other than a single hot
> origin — one should not regard the standard story as the only interpretation.”
> Co-authored with Fred Hoyle across various publications (1960s–1990s), presenting
> the Quasi-Steady State mechanisms for thermalizing starlight into microwave radiation.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Thomas Gold, astrophysicist & former professor of astronomy at Cornell University
> “The idea that time itself came into existence at the Big Bang seems to mix physics
> with metaphysics; caution is required.”From essays and interviews (1980s) critiquing
> the overextension of physical models into metaphysical assertions regarding the
> genesis of time.

> 
> ## BIG BANG THEORY
> 
> Arno Penzias, radio astronomer and Nobel Laureate in Physics
> “We must not mistake an attractive, successful model for the unique truth; the
> Big Bang remains a model open to revision.”From retrospectives and scientific 
> interviews (2000s), reminding researchers that cosmological frameworks remain 
> provisional despite empirical successes.
